February 26, 2008

Dear Mr. Brown

Dear Gordon Brown,

It was with great sadness and, frankly, annoyance that I read about your latest idea to try to stop the influx of what can only be described as the scourage of society - the immigrant. You have plans to change immigration laws for anyone outside of the European Economic Area. While many pundits and legalese types debate these changes with regards to "non-whites" or, as my xenophobic stepmother-in-law might put it "those people", the truth is you catch a great deal of "whites" or, as I'm led to read between the lines, "people who we're not targetting but are caught in the net anyway".

Like myself.

I came to your country 4 years ago under a Highly Skilled Migrant visa, which I qualified for and paid for myself. From the day I stepped foot out of Heathrow I have been working, without cessation. I have been working on projects that contribute to British society and British businesses.

I pay taxes. In fact, I pay the highest amount of taxes as set forth in your country's finances. I pay as much in tax as the average millinonaire should do, only I'm not a millionaire and they're more clever than I am and have ways of hiding their money from you. I pay council tax, to the tune of £200 a month, for which I occasionally get my bins emptied (although not at Christmastime, when my binmen cannot be bothered). I pay utilities and car/home/health insurance. I pay car tax to use your roads and a TV license to watch your BBC. I have a UK driving license. I pay a fortune to take your public transportation to get to other parts of the country, for which I am rewarded with tardy and overcrowded trains. I own a house here, or at least the bank does and I thoughtfully remember to pay them every month. I got to pay a ransom in stamp duty to buy said house, as well. I have a British partner and two half-British children who have British passports.

I moan about the weather. I eat my sprouts with my sunday roast. On Boxing Day I get my walking shoes on and go for a walk like the rest of the country. I avoid conversation on the tube like everyone else and can order a pint with a joke back to the barkeep. I know not to book a chimney sweep during wedding season and I have learned the difference between an A-level and an O-level. I watch Last Night at the Proms and can even sing God Save the Queen, even if I know it as My Country Tis of Thee. Heck, I even recycle.

I wonder, then, why it would be necessary to prove I am "integrated into British society". Apparently, the above aren't enough to prove it. I already learned how difficult it was to prove I speak English, I can't wait to go through that one again (you are reading this letter in Farsi, Mr. Brown. Congratulations, I had no idea you were so adept.) I now need to look into enjoying charity work and being involved in my local community. I'm very excited about both options, especially as the full-time working mother of soon-to-be 5 month old twins means I have bags of spare time.

You already moved the goal posts on me once. Previously I only had to be here 4 years to get indefinite leave to remain or citizenship. Now it's 5 years, a horrendous increase in price, citizenship tests and proof required that I'm "an active citizen" - for both indefinite leave to remain and citizenship! There is nothing to be gained by not trying for citizenship now, and a huge investment of time and money (I can't seem to find consistent info, but I think £1000 is a little steep, personally). And speaking of cost, apparently now the price is higher for immigrants with children. My twins and I thank you from the bottom of our wallets.

It's funny - I get the impression that you don't want me here, Mr. Brown. I'm not sure what I did wrong, on the whole I think I contribute to society here, and further I actually genuinely love living here. If this is a concern about me or people like me "taking advantage of services reserved for British subjects", then let me assure you, I have not nor will I be on unemployment. Not only because I will seek active employment immediately should I lose my job, but because according to my visa I have no recourse to public funds so I don't use them.

More and more I feel unwanted and, frankly, despicable if the government arguments are to be believed. I hear Women's Hour on BBC 4 - Women's Hour, the bastien of calm and level-headedness! - talking about "British values". The disgraceful and disgusting BNP shove leaflets through my door describing how vile immigrants are to society as a whole. I'm often tempted to tell them that just because I am white doesn't mean I don't represent that which they loathe.

It's apparently what you loathe, too, Mr. Brown. I want to seek British citizenship over indefinite leave to remain so that I too can have the same citizenship as my children, and the three of us will be dual citizens of America and Britain. I want to seek British citizenship so that every three years I don't have to perform like a poodle to get another visa. I want to seek British citizenship so that when I pay my taxes and walk my dog in National Trust lands and ride the public transport infrastructure I'll feel like I have a right to be there, and that I can represent these things to the best of my ability.

Like many others, I would like to be a British citizen.

Britain just doesn't want us, apparently.

I'll show myself out, and I'll wipe the doorknob as I go, so not to leave any smudges from my grubby immigrant hands.

Sincerely,
Helen Adelaide

Posted by: Everydaystranger at 08:01 AM | Comments (12) | Add Comment
Post contains 1021 words, total size 6 kb.

1 Amen. After all the agony involved in getting my ILR, I'm now trying to figure out a way to go for citizenship when I'm eligible in November and hopefully dodge all the new and improved hoops that will be in place (they hope) by next Spring. Earned citizenship by way of forced community service?!?! And WTF is a 'probationary citizen' supposed to be anyway? They talk about not wanting people to be in limbo, but that seems a thousand times worse than just being a permanent resident. I particularly enjoy the bits where they talk about preventing immigrants from utilizing the few benefits that are available, including the NHS. As much as I love being here, there are some days when I regret not bringing my husband to the US instead. The USCIS isn't much better than BIA in a lot of ways but it's nothing on this level.

Posted by: tanis at February 26, 2008 11:09 AM (6cH2N)

2 *hmph* So you have time to write letters to your children and to government figures, but no time for a blog post? I'm deeply hurt. Oh, and doesn't Mr Brown realize that this sort of thing was why people left GB for America a few years back?

Posted by: ~Easy at February 26, 2008 11:50 AM (XD24A)

3 Wow. Talk about your hoops and red tape. Like you needed more stress.

Posted by: Lisa at February 26, 2008 02:34 PM (EcHBm)

4 I was going to say "Wow - they're even harder on immigrants than we are in the U.S." - then I remembered Bush's fence. So I guess you're still ahead if they're not building a fence to keep you out?

Posted by: Tracy at February 26, 2008 02:40 PM (sYEOB)

5 ummm, Tracy - the fence is for the ILLEGAL immigrants. Helen is a LEGAL immigrant. Big difference. (For the record, my MOTHER is/was a legal immigrant to the US. Arrived in '63, got a green card shortly thereafter and became a US citizen in '78.) For the law abiding in the US, this process is no where near as difficult as Helen is describing for the UK.

Posted by: Clancy at February 26, 2008 03:04 PM (X+xFB)

6 Clancy, We would have to waste a lot of money on a fence here. England has a huge moat.

Posted by: Charles at February 26, 2008 04:00 PM (iVaTz)

7 The points you allude to in your post remind me of my frustration with the immigration policies and rhetoric here in the states. Logic is apparetly not a consideration on either side of the pond. We keep out well qualified and needed immigrants and vilify those who are willing and want to work at jobs that go unfilled, unwanted and untaken by "citizens" who had rather enjoy a life of unemplyment benefits. So sad; I had assumed our British cousins were more rational.

Posted by: Charles at February 26, 2008 04:08 PM (iVaTz)

8 I sympathize with your red tape ordeal. I work with lots of legal immigrants who have to dance the limbo under a flaming pole -or something like it- every year or so to remain here legally. However, I am curious as to one of your points: is it possible for you, an American citizen, to become a citizen of another country without first renouncing your American citizenship? I know that that won't be a problem for your children, but I was kind of under the impression that the US was loathe to let you become citizens of another country without renouncing your US ties first. However, I will defer to your firsthand experience, since it's not something I deal with myself. Anyway, I know it will all work out for you. Eventually.

Posted by: physics geek at February 26, 2008 04:49 PM (MT22W)

9 As the American wife of a non-American in the USA (but not a Mexican, who seem to be the target of as much poisonous red tape as a country can throw) - I can tell you from experience that it is scads easier over here than over there. That said, one of the only reasons WE don't live over there instead of over here is because while my husband can stroll over the moat and settle happily with our son as a citizen of EEA country, he is afraid I would be carted off and made to live in the UK equivilent of the twilight zone. (((HELEN))) Should I send some mac & cheese as moral support?

Posted by: Elizabeth at February 26, 2008 05:50 PM (DyeGv)

10 I always laugh at how people talk of their disdain for immigrants, fully realising that as an American, I'm probably one myself. I guess it's because I'm white and not Eastern European, I'm ok. Bearing in mind most of those non-white and Eastern Europeans got here the same way I did (legally) and are largely more qualified and better educated than the native population, SHUT UP. Ahem.

Posted by: MsPrufrock at February 26, 2008 10:06 PM (1NDGw)

11 Brilliant letter. Can I use it? Seriously, I was thinking much the same things when I saw his new proposals for immigrants like us. My husband is British. My kids are half-British. I have indefinite leave to remain and we pay all our taxes, thank you very much. I think I need to get my application for British citizenship in NOW (I just became eligible this month) before all this crap kicks in.

Posted by: ewe_aer_here at February 27, 2008 10:32 PM (B8Bqx)

12 Brilliant letter. Loved reading it. I'm greatful I don't have to worry about citizenship, since this is only a four year stay for us. I can't imagine being put through such impossible hoops and how doing so can possibly make you more British than council tax does. OUCH. Also, I LOVE that you have a blog in addition to Flickr. LOVE it.

Posted by: Kelly Anne at March 02, 2008 04:46 PM (dhuNF)

Hide Comments | Add Comment

Comments are disabled. Post is locked.
25kb generated in CPU 0.0175, elapsed 0.0619 seconds.
35 queries taking 0.0549 seconds, 136 records returned.
Powered by Minx 1.1.6c-pink.